What's up with PhilHealth?

The Philippines' health insurer is set to get zero subsidy from the national government in 2025

By Prinz Magtulis

Dec. 30, 2024


Criticisms mounted over the weekend against the proposed P6.3-trillion national budget for 2025 in a last-ditch effort from various groups to convince Congress and President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. to "correct" next year's outlay ahead of its scheduled signing on Monday, Dec. 30.
A key contention among critics is the stark drop in funding for social protection programs, including a P50-billion cut in conditional cash transfers to the poor known as the Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino and a decline in education budget. But nothing alarmed observers more than the zero allocation to the Philippine Health Insurance Corp. (PhilHealth).
A "correction" to the budget however will not come easy. Under the Constitution, Marcos can exercise his veto powers over line items in the budget, but cannot realign funds already appropriated by Congress under the bill. That means he cannot augment any agency budget. An option will be to veto the entire outlay, but that would mean having the government run under this year's budget come Jan. 1, leaving new programs unfunded until Congress passes a revised budget.
PhilHealth, the Philippines' state insurer that oversees the enforcement of the universal healthcare program, was supposed to get P74.43 billion in government subsidy under Marcos's budget proposal to Congress. But the bicameral conference committee — a group of select members of the House of Representatives and the Senate that finalizes the budget before the president signs it— surprisingly removed that budget in the final draft of the budget bill.

PhilHealth is a government-owned corporation and generates its own revenues mainly through premiums paid by its registered members and interest from investments.

By law however, the government is mandated to provide healthcare to all Filipinos, not only PhilHealth members, so to cover for those people who cannot pay premiums, the national government gives PhilHealth money every year.

These co-called “indirect contributors” count as members senior citizens who are no longer able to work,

the poor,

and the disabled.

As of June 2024, there were about 26.1 million people who depend on this subsidy, PhilHealth data showed.

On an annual basis, these so-called “indirect contributors” reached around 37 million in 2023, about 3% lower than the previous year, PhilHealth data showed. The dip was due to a lower number of poor individuals covered (worthy to note that PhilHealth registrations rose during the same period).
Yet even with this decline, over one in three people benefitting from PhilHealth still fall under this category and depend on government subsidy. PhilHealth said it can continue to service its indigent members. Premium paying members should remain unaffected.
On the other hand, data showed that under the Marcos Jr. administration, the national government’s subsidy to PhilHealth has consistently dropped. This was despite what is supposedly a steady stream of revenues to fund it, some of which come from the “sin” tax laws that hiked tobacco and liquor duties every year since 2012, as well as revenue share from gambling and lotto operations of the Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. (Pagcor) and Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO), respectively.

Shrinking PhilHealth subsidy under Marcos turns to zero in 2025

Share of revenue source

LGU contributions

Universal healthcare begins

Start of Marcos budget

100%

Interest

Government subsidy

75

50

25

Premium contributions

0

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

LGU contributions

Universal healthcare begins

Start of Marcos budget

100%

Interest

Government subsidy

75

50

25

Premium contributions

0

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

Universal healthcare begins

Start of

Marcos budget

100%

Interest

LGU

contributions

75

Government subsidy

50

Premium contributions

25

0

2016

2018

2020

2022

2024

Source: PhilHealth

The universal healthcare law, passed in 2019, also mandates that additional revenues generated from higher tobacco and liquor taxes be funneled to PhilHealth. Also under that law, the government hiked PhilHealth premium contributions but also mandated that an increase in contributions should be matched with a "corresponding increase in benefits."
But this has not happened. Worse, even current benefits are barely meeting Filipinos’ health needs. The share of PhilHealth on annual health expenditures by Filipinos sank to just 10.2% in 2023, the lowest in comparable data from 2014.

PhilHealth share of Filipinos' health expenses falls to lowest in a decade

Annual share of health expenditures

Universal healthcare begins

50%

Out of pocket

40

Government

30

20

PhilHealth

10

10.2%

HMO

0

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

Universal healthcare begins

50%

Out of pocket

40

Government

30

20

PhilHealth

10

10.2%

HMO

0

2014

2016

2018

2020

2022

Universal healthcare begins

50%

Out of pocket

40

Government

30

20

PhilHealth

10

10.2%

HMO

0

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

Note: Government share covers both national and local governments. Data earlier than 2014 not available due to methodology changes that may make the data incomparable.
Source: Philippine Statistics Authority

Health officials acknowledged that services provided by PhilHealth had barely improved despite the hike in premium contributions. This, in turn, resulted in a surge in PhilHealth's reserves. The Department of Health has pointed to these reserves, amounting to P488.11 billion as of the first quarter of 2024, as sufficient buffer against the loss in government subsidy next year.
However, IBON Foundation, a think tank, blasted this justification: "It is no surprise that the agency's substantial savings come from spending less on benefit packages that it receives in contributions," IBON said in a Dec. 23 statement.
Reserves are accumulated through excess profits through the years, but profits are prone to excessive swings given rising healthcare costs. For instance, data showed that PhilHealth booked a P12.06 billion in profits in 2019, only to reverse P25 billion in net loss in 2020 when the pandemic struck.
By 2021, PhilHealth cut its losses, but was still in the red, and only managed to recover by 2022. Even then, reports back in September 2022 quoted a PhilHealth official to have said that the health fund's actuarial life – the period over which it can service current and future obligations to its members – could only run up to 2027 even with additional revenues. PhilHealth officials have since taken back that statement.

Sources:

PhilHealth, Philippine Statistics Authority

Copyright 2024 - The Data Dictionary Project